Television’s most-loved animated family, Marge, Homer, Bart, Lisa and Maggie Simpson. Photo: DISNEY
It’s nearly 31 years now since “The Simpsons” made its debut on American television, and just short of three decades it has graced Australian TV screens. That is an incredible feat in itself.
But this is also a show which has not only just endured, but managed to worm its way into so many aspects of modern popular culture. You can’t go more than five minutes on virtually any social media platform without someone using an image from the show as a meme or comment on practically any situation.
For those of us who have literally grown up with the show, it at times has felt like it was part of us. “The Simpsons” is in fact almost six years older than me, and as a result, has managed to define a fair chunk of my life.
I’ve been watching it as long as I can remember, before I can remember, even. Religiously, every night at 6pm, I’d tune in. Whether at home, at my best mates’ house across the road, or wherever I was that had a TV, I’d be there.
It was so embedded in my life that not only did I watch it pretty much seven days a week for the first 13 (give or take) years of my life, but I had a massive stash of whatever Simpsons memorabilia I could get my hands on.
Shopping bags from the supermarket? Check. Soft toys? Check. Keyrings, stickers, posters? Check. Books, specifically “Bart’s Guide to Life” and “Simpsons’ Comics Extravaganza”? Check. “The Simpsons: Hit and Run” as well as “The Simpsons Game” on PS2? Check.
Various Bart Simpson related t-shirts and pyjamas from the boys section at Target because apparently girls can’t like subversive, anti-authority cartoon characters? Also check.
Lisa Simpson did not get enough merchandise 20 years ago. It annoyed me then, it annoys me now and people marketing clothes to girls need to realise that their audience is a lot more diverse in taste than they seem to realise. But I digress.
I didn’t realise just how much of my life I had dedicated to “The Simpsons” until quite recently, however.
It wasn’t until Disney+ launched in Australia and they had a several day (might’ve been a couple weeks) long marathon on Fox8 to essentially say goodbye, as it went to streaming, that I realised how many episodes I had actually seen.
For the record, it’s every episode up until the end of Season 15, and then scattered episodes here and there until Season 19. That surprised me, because I had assumed that all the re-runs at 6pm hadn’t really covered that much ground, and yet I seem to have seen roughly around 400 episodes.
That being the case, it would be nigh on impossible for me to assemble a list of my favourite episodes. Mainly because I tried already before writing this and only managed to get the list down to 182.
PLEASE HELP US CONTINUE TO THRIVE BY BECOMING AN OFFICIAL FOOTYOLOGY PATRON. JUST CLICK THIS LINK.
So, instead, I’ve asked people who know me best what episodes they mostly associate with me. My mum instantly went off the top of her head: “Baby Translator, Chanel Dress, Monorail, Lisa’s Saxophone.”
Which translates to: “Brother, Can You Spare Two Dimes?” (S03E24), “Scenes from the Class Struggle in Springfield” (S07E24), “Marge vs. the Monorail” (S04E12) and “Lisa’s Pony” (S03E08).
My friends also got back to me with almost instant answers: “Oh Brother, Where Art Thou?” (S02E15), “Lisa the Beauty Queen” (S04E04), “Mr. Plow” (S04E09), “I Love Lisa” (S04E15), “Homer’s Barbershop Quartet” (S05E01), “Lisa vs. Malibu Stacy” (S05E14), “Bart Gets an Elephant” (S05E17), “The Boy Who Knew Too Much” (S05E20) and “Two Dozen and One Greyhounds” (S06E20).
Funnily enough, I’d never pegged myself as anything more than a casual fan. But it is a show which has infiltrated millennial culture to such an extent that most of the time I don’t even realise how often I quote it in real life.
Every time I get frogurt, my mind immediately goes to “The Treehouse of Horror III”, with the terribly-cursed frogurt and potassium benzoate. I tried to make a “Flaming Homer” (no, I will NOT be calling it a Flaming Moe) once and nearly died. It was revolting, but I had to at least try it. And I still haven’t quite mastered “a single plum in perfume floating in a man’s hat” yet.
But what does strike me, though, as I know it has similarly struck many Simpsons fans, is how many of my favourite episodes, and those to which people constantly refer, are from the first 12 seasons. And that’s being generous. It’s mostly seasons 2 through 8.
In hindsight, it’s amazing such a long-running show had such a solid run for that long. Most shows don’t have a run that solid ever.
Season 3 is without a doubt my favourite. Every single episode is good, if not great. Season 4 is a close runner-up.
So when did “The Simpsons” begin to “jump the shark”? I think in Season 8, but to me it didn’t become patently obvious until “The Principal and the Pauper” in Season 9’.
I know some of you knew I was going to say this. And that’s because it’s simply the obvious, most horrendous thing to happen to that point in the show’s history. To completely erase Seymour Skinner’s entire character backstory in one fell swoop for no real gain is among the most bewilderingly stupid things I’ve seen “The Simpsons” do.
And as it was put by Super Eyepatch Wolf in his superb video essay “The Fall of The Simpsons: How it Happened”: “Like a lot of seasons 8 to 10, the episode itself isn’t particularly bad, and there’s even some great jokes in there. But the problem comes from how it shatters the fictional integrity of one of the show’s most beloved characters.
“The entire episode is based on the premise that the upbringing that made Principal Skinner who he is and is so integral to his character, never actually happened … This episode was telling us that a character who’s been built up carefully for eight years isn’t real and never was. All for the sake of a cheap gag narrative that ultimately goes nowhere and says nothing.”
After this point, “The Simpsons” becomes increasingly self-referential, even referring to “The Principal and the Pauper” in season 11’s “Behind the Laughter”, a parody of VH1’s “Behind the Music”, by presenting a clip from the episode with the appropriately dramatic narrator deriding the show’s increasingly “gimmicky and nonsensical plots”.
But self-referential does not necessarily equate with self-awareness. As can be seen by their increasing reliance on celebrity guest stars being the gag. In the golden age of the show, if you will, celebrity guest stars usually came in and played completely different characters.
And it worked magnificently, such as with Danny DeVito’s Herb Powell or Meryl Streep’s Jessica Lovejoy being essential to the plots of “Oh Brother, Where Art Thou?” (S02E15), “Brother, Can You Spare Two Dimes?” (S03E24) and “Bart’s Girlfriend” (S06E07).
However, in “new” Simpsons or “Zombie Simpsons”, as in “Lisa Goes Gaga” (S23E22), the celebrity being there is the gag. That’s it, that’s the joke. Oh, did you miss it? So did I.
Apparently, Tony Blair showing up and saying: “Hello. Welcome to the United Kingdom” is a joke now. We know this because Lisa says “Wow, Prime Minister Tony Blair!” to drive the point home, and it’s used as an attempt at a joke about the UK tourism lobby.
Except the episode in question, “The Regina Monologues” (S15E04), aired at the height of opposition to the Iraq War, and is a far cry from the same show which skewered George H.W. Bush in “Two Bad Neighbors” (S07E13).
Even “The Simpsons Movie’ suffers from the same problem. Literally the only jokes I remember are Green Day playing “Nearer My God to Thee”, the massive dome and “Spiderpig”.
The first joke is even less funny than I remember it to be at the time, and I say this as a massive Green Day fan. I’m not even going to touch on “When You Dish Upon a Star” (S10E05) or “Homer vs. Dignity” (S12E05), because if you know, you know.
“The Simpsons” at its height was an explosive comedy satirising and parodying everything it could without reverence and regard.
It was brilliant. It valued its characters, its setting and its audience. It’s some of the most quotable, nuanced, greatest television to which you’ll ever bear witness. I’ll love it forever and treasure the massive impact it’s made on my life. I doubt I’d have the sense of humour I have now if not for early seasons of the show.
I’ll revere those first 10 seasons for the rest of my life. But it’s sad to see what it’s devolved into.
I’ve tried so many times to watch newer episodes, and by newer I really mean Season 19, so not that new. And I just find them impossible to watch. The gags aren’t there, every member of the Simpsons family is a faulty caricature of what they were 20 years ago, the animation is jarring, and it’s ultimately become a parody of itself.
But I will always, always love what its very best gave me.
Andrea… I’m rewatching Marge vs the Monorail… I’d forgotten how much gold was packed into the ep.
Brilliant. Agree completely on what the golden years were – even though some characters were ill-defined (remember that Ralph Wiggum wasn’t really Ralph Wiggum in Lisa’s Pony – “What man can tame her?”).
Marge vs the Monorail is my favourite ep (so many great lines). I knew the girl I met ten years ago was a keeper when she told me she had a favourite Simpsons episode (Homer vs God)…. there were other reasons too. (c;
What amazes me is that so many people think The Simpsons was pretty much garbage after Season 10, but it is still going. The show has now been terrible for twice as long as it has been good.
I tend to work off “quotabilty”, and that has pretty much evaporated since Season 12. Which is why, at a stretch, I’d give it until Season 12 before I write it off completely as there is still some decent Simpsons gear present (eg, prank monkey, the area code split, the navy boy-band).
Oh yes, Ralph Wiggum in Lisa’s Pony is one of those weird moments where you’re not quite sure what’s just happened. Definitely not the same boy who ate paste.
By Homer vs God, I can only assume you mean Homer the Heretic? In which case, I congratulate you and your partner on your excellent taste in Simpsons episodes.
The Simpsons is almost untouchable, I don’t think it’ll ever be cancelled at this point. No matter how bad it gets, it’ll keep going because it brings in massive advertising revenue. The re-syndication money alone is a massive source of revenue for Fox/Disney. More episodes, more re-syndication.
I’d agree with you on the quotability factor. Definitely not nearly as quotable after S12. There are still some gems in those early teens season, they’re just few and far between. I do, however, love ‘New Kids on the Blecch’ the navy boy band episode, in question. But that might just be because I was a massive *NSYNC fan at the time.
I felt like most of the peripheral characters weren’t well-defined in the early eps. Smithers was a very dark colour early on (and lacking the gay vibe), Lenny & Karl didn’t really have characters of their own, Chief Wiggum wasn’t completely hopeless etc etc.
At the time of Lisa’s Pony the writers hadn’t even decided that Ralph was Wiggum’s son.
Yes, I meant “Homer the Heretic” (oops). I think my (now) partner called it that when we just met (and I knew what she meant and the episode obtained that name in my head).
I accept and appreciate your congratulations. Based on your lists, you also have excellent taste (particularly for someone who had to go back to watch the older episodes; contrasted with me who was in prime viewing age when season 1 came out – although I probably didn’t really appreciate it until a couple of years later when my Year 10 English teacher came back from school holidays and said he watched a heap of The Simpsons over the break and how great it was).
I’d love to know what the stream count is for each episode on Disney+. Why anyone would purposefully put on an episode from Season 13, would be a conversation that philosophers would argue over for centuries.
I don’t know who still watches the new episodes. I had a brief argument with someone online where he defended newer episodes as “they’re still okay”… which is not a defence when they used to be absolutely spectacular.
S12 gets a pass on quotability because of this scene in the Tale of Two Springfields:
Homer: Oh, yeah? They think they’re better than us, huh? Bart, c’mere a minute!
Bart: You c’mere a minute!
Homer: Oh, yeah?
Gold.
When I talk about how great The Simpsons was, it always comes down to the writing. There’s a scene in Homer the Vigilante that epitomises this (at least in my humble opinion):
Lisa: If you’re the police, who will police the police?
Homer: I dunno, Coast Guard?
It’s not even a joke with a lot of layers, but I can’t think of the name of any service that would be funnier than “Coast Guard” and you just feel like they really took their time getting it right.
I could talk about this shit for hours because it does crack me so consistently up.
My brother and I quote it to each other frequently – one day he answered the phone with “You’ll have to speak up, I’m wearing a towel.” I lost it.
Sorry… just blabbering now.
You’re definitely right about that. I didn’t know they hadn’t decided that Ralph was Wiggum’s son at that point but it makes sense.
The thing for me is, I didn’t really go out of my way to watch “older” episodes, it just happened. Because that’s the way Channel 10 programmed the reruns. But it worked out pretty well in the end.
I’d be curious to know too. I’m going through it all on Disney+ at the minute, I’m going to at least try and watch every season. But I don’t hold out much hope for later seasons. At all. As to S13 and above, from writing this article there’s a couple people who seem to genuinely love those teen seasons, and who will defend them to the end of the earth. Which I definitely respect, if not agree with.
If you’re interested, the video essay linked to in the article also has its own links to various Simpsons essays and discussion boards on the same topic, it’s been a really fascinating deep dive for me.
Sorry, Andrea – I wandered off. I have to remind myself to come back and check this article… and I forgot.
When I said “go back”, it was really more an acknowledgement that you *watched* the older episodes. As the animation changed (improved) and style of the show changed (turned to garbage) it would have been easy for you (as a very young person) to dismiss the older episodes as being “shit because they’re old”.
A recent conversation with a mate reminded me that when The Simpsons was on in the early ’90s there was very little else on (where I lived, we had three TV channels)… It’s no wonder that I have so many bits of episodes stuck in my head, I’ve seen them countless times.
How goes the re-watch project? Where are you up to?
I did follow a couple of the links on that video… but the time require to dive into that rabbit hole eludes me. The central premise (that the Principal and the Pauper was the beginning of the end) had not occurred to me. I never liked the episode much, but I’d never really thought about it with any depth.
My question would be: do the people who defend the “teens” prefer them or just say that they’re good? Not sure I can muster respect for their position though. At best, they are misguided… if they think the teens are superior, then they’re delusional.
That’s a fair assumption. I think as the animation improved it actually became worse to look at? I caught a couple later episodes recently and saw some stuff from the movie and it just looked awful in comparison to the earlier episodes. Like, very oddly sanitised?
I had pay TV as a kid but I actually spent a lot of my time watching free to air, as opposed to pay TV as none of my friends had it. So as a result, we watched a lot of The Simpsons reruns along with obligatory shows like Daria as a run in.
It’s been on a bit of a pause, fairly busy. But I’ve watched all of S1 again and am half way through S2. Just kind of taking my time to savour the jokes a bit more. Just rewatched “One Fish, Two Fish, Blowfish, Blue Fish” S02E11. It’s the kind of episode I doubt they even make anymore. It’s got great jokes, a full emotional journey for Homer as well as the other characters. The five stages of grief joke gets me every time. It’ll probably pick up a bit in the coming weeks, I’m hoping to try and get into the teens seasons in mid-January. I say “try” because I’m just not sure I can make it past S12, but the challenge’s been set.
It hadn’t occurred to me that The Principal and the Pauper was a downturn either until I found this video essay late last year, during the 24 hour Simpsons marathon on Fox8. I wouldn’t say it’s the absolute turning point, but it’s a useful benchmark. You can see the decline a bit before that, more markedly afterwards, although there are still high points. It’s once you get to S13, that there’s the real drop off.
There are a few very ardent defenders of S13 and of the Mike Scully years. I remain unconvinced. In the end, I guess it’s all subjective but it feels objective when most of the world seems to agree. I will admit to liking some of those teen episodes, but not with the same kind of enjoyment or quotability of earlier episodes.
Yes… the cleanliness of the animation in the later episodes does feel wrong… the word “slimy” comes to mind. All very smooth. My partner (who is *awesome*) gave me an original animation cel for a birthday – it hangs on my office wall as a constant reminder of “the good ol’ days”.
The less said about the Movie, the better.
I remember Fox8 used to play about six hours of back-to-back old episodes on Sunday mornings. Aside from the sheer number of adverts, that was pretty good. (I acquired Paytv in later life).
“One Fish, Two Fish..” is a damn good one. Yes, I also love “Mr Simpson, your progress astounds me”.
And when he answers the phone while recording a video for Maggie… Barney searching his apartment for $50, Marge figuring Homer was still alive from warm drool to the closing scene after Homer claims that he’ll live life to its fullest.
It always annoyed me that the TV channels shied away from re-playing “Bart The General” from S1. I remember seeing it when it first aired and then not again for years.
The idea of “Zombie Simpsons” (or whatever you want to call it) is about as universally accepted as climate change. In an area where objectivity doesn’t really exist, that’s about as close as you get to it. Popularity is never a guarantee of quality, but in this case it’s not a bad measure.
People who argue differently are either trolling, delusional, captious or they got the idea that having this opinion made them *interesting* (or they’ve been got at by Fox/Disney). There may be a couple of watchable ones buried in there, but that’s about as much as I’d concede. I don’t even understand how they get an average score of 6.
No judgement from me if you give up after S12. I would describe your plan to watch them all as masochistic at best. You’re talking roughly six days of your life to watch seasons 13 – 30… I’m *positive* you can think of something more worthwhile to do with that time. (c: